This intriguing title refers to a key question within the narrative of Karen Cushman’s Newbery Medal-winning novel, *The Midwife’s Apprentice*. The story follows a young, nameless girl in medieval England who is taken in by a gruff but ultimately kind midwife known as Jane the Midwife. “Brat,” as she is initially called, gradually learns the trade and eventually earns the name Alyce. The identity of the mysterious Magister becomes a significant element in her journey of self-discovery and professional development.
The Magister’s Role in the Narrative
The Magister represents a figure of authority and advanced medical knowledge. He embodies the formal, academic side of medicine in contrast to the practical, experiential approach of traditional midwives.
Symbolism of the Unknown
The mystery surrounding the Magister contributes to the novel’s exploration of themes like social hierarchy and the acquisition of knowledge in a medieval setting.
Driving Force for Alyce’s Growth
The question of the Magister’s identity fuels Alyce’s curiosity and ambition, pushing her to strive for greater understanding and mastery of her craft.
A Catalyst for Plot Development
The eventual reveal of the Magister’s identity serves as a pivotal moment in the story, impacting Alyce’s future and solidifying her sense of self.
Reflection of Medieval Medical Practices
The Magister’s existence highlights the evolving landscape of medicine during the medieval period and the interplay between traditional practices and emerging academic approaches.
Contrast Between Practical and Theoretical Knowledge
The narrative juxtaposes the Magister’s theoretical knowledge with Jane the Midwife’s practical experience, raising questions about the nature and value of different forms of learning.
The Power of Mentorship
While the Magister represents formal education, Jane the Midwife provides Alyce with essential mentorship and practical skills, emphasizing the importance of both in personal and professional growth.
Theme of Empowerment
Alyce’s pursuit of knowledge and her eventual encounter with the Magister contribute to her journey of empowerment and self-realization.
Tips for Engaging with the Story
Consider the historical context of medieval medicine and societal structures.
Pay attention to the contrasting approaches to healing represented by Jane and the Magister.
Reflect on Alyce’s evolving understanding of herself and her profession.
Analyze the symbolism and significance of the Magister’s eventual reveal.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why is the Magister’s identity kept a secret for a portion of the book?
The mystery surrounding the Magister’s identity creates suspense and encourages readers to consider the different forms of medical knowledge and authority present in the story.
What does the Magister represent in the novel?
The Magister symbolizes formal medical training and the growing influence of academic approaches to healing during the medieval period.
How does the Magister’s reveal impact Alyce’s journey?
The revelation provides Alyce with a deeper understanding of the medical landscape and further solidifies her own path as a skilled and confident midwife.
What is the significance of the contrast between Jane and the Magister?
The contrast highlights the differing values and approaches to healing, emphasizing the importance of both practical experience and theoretical knowledge.
Why is this question important to the novel?
The question drives Alyce’s curiosity and motivates her to seek greater knowledge and understanding, ultimately contributing to her growth and development.
What does the Magister’s character reveal about medieval society?
The Magister’s presence reveals the evolving nature of medical practice and the emergence of more formalized, academic approaches to healing alongside traditional methods.
Understanding the role and significance of the Magister adds a deeper layer of appreciation for Cushman’s exploration of themes like mentorship, self-discovery, and the evolution of medical knowledge in *The Midwife’s Apprentice*.
